Keegan O'Toole
NCAA championship record, 2021–2025. Regular-season results are not included.
5tournaments
25wins
3losses
2individual titles
6wins by fall
NCAA career
Every NCAA bout · 28
| Round | W/L | Opponent | Seed | Opp. seed | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 · 174 lb | |||||
| Round of 32 | W | Michael Wilson · Rider (NJ) | 1 | 33 | Fall 4:24 |
| Round of 16 | W | Lorenzo Norman · Stanford (CA) | 1 | 16 | Dec 10–8 |
| Quarterfinal | W | Lennox Wolak · Virginia Tech | 1 | 24 | MD 13–1 |
| Semifinal | W | Cade DeVos · South Dakota State | 1 | 13 | Dec 7–6 |
| Final | L | Dean Hamiti Jr. · Oklahoma State | 1 | 3 | Dec 1–4 |
| 2024 · 165 lb | |||||
| Round of 32 | W | Jack Thomsen · Northern Iowa | 1 | 33 | Fall 2:55 |
| Round of 16 | W | Will Miller · Appalachian State (NC) | 1 | 16 | Fall 5:58 |
| Quarterfinal | W | Antrell Taylor · Nebraska | 1 | 8 | Fall 4:06 |
| Semifinal | L | David Carr · Iowa State | 1 | 4 | Dec 6–8 |
| Consolation semifinal | W | Hunter Garvin · Stanford (CA) | 1 | 20 | TF 17–1 |
| 3rd-place bout | W | Michael Caliendo III · Iowa | 1 | 6 | Dec 12–8 |
| 2023 · 165 lb | |||||
| Round of 32 | W | Wyatt Sheets · Oklahoma State | 2 | 31 | MD 13–5 |
| Round of 16 | W | Justin McCoy · Virginia | 2 | 15 | Dec 5–2 |
| Quarterfinal | W | Carson Kharchla · Ohio State | 2 | 10 | TF 19–4 |
| Semifinal | W | Cam Amine · Michigan | 2 | 11 | Dec 6–0 |
| Final | W | David Carr · Iowa State | 2 | 1 | Dec 8–2 |
| 2022 · 165 lb | |||||
| Round of 32 | W | Caleb Fish · Michigan State | 2 | 31 | Fall 0:52 |
| Round of 16 | W | Anthony Valencia · Arizona State | 2 | 18 | Dec 7–0 |
| Quarterfinal | W | Carson Kharchla · Ohio State | 2 | 7 | Dec 2–0 |
| Semifinal | W | Cam Amine · Michigan | 2 | 6 | Dec 4–0 |
| Final | W | Shane Griffith · Stanford (CA) | 2 | 5 | Dec 6–5 |
| 2021 · 165 lb | |||||
| Round of 32 | W | Jake Silverstein · Rider (NJ) | 6 | 27 | Fall 4:10 |
| Round of 16 | W | Cam Amine · Michigan | 6 | 11 | Dec 5–2 |
| Quarterfinal | L | Jake Wentzel · Pittsburgh (PA) | 6 | 3 | Dec 6–9 |
| Consolation round 4 | W | Luke Weber · North Dakota State | 6 | 9 | Dec 5–1 |
| Consolation round 5 | W | Anthony Valencia · Arizona State | 6 | 2 | TF 16–1 |
| Consolation semifinal | W | Zach Hartman · Bucknell (PA) | 6 | 5 | MD 17–4 |
| 3rd-place bout | W | Travis Wittlake Jr. · Oklahoma State | 6 | 10 | Dec 4–3 |